Sears Mattress Reviews

Sears Specifics

Sears has been a major name in all things home for generations, selling everything to keep both indoor and outdoor living spaces working well.

What does that mean about their selection? In terms of mattresses, they have always been devoted to having a wider price selection than many department store competitors, which has been a big win for customers.

But with that selection comes a hidden truth:

The prices are often much higher for the materials used.

This is because Sears has to pay its sales people, keep its store operating, and make a profit. Also, they sell other brands that also have to make a profit too, so oftentimes the foam or coil construction is marked up many times before you buy it.

What you are buying is department store convenience and name recognition.

Read on to learn more about their selection...or browse our top rated alternatives.

Mattress Brands
Sears has done a good job offering a wide range of selection to their customers. However, not all mattress brands are created equal.

We'll go through each brand in depth and discuss the positives and negatives so you can understand what you are buying.

So here they are...

#1 Tempur-PedicTempur-Pedic became a household name in the 90's with its rapid growth of memory foam mattresses. Since then, they have expanded their offerings to including pocketed coil systems and cooling gel foam. These mattresses get love from customers, but are much more expensive than comparable products from online brands.

The pros: High end mattresses featuring memory foam.

The cons: Prices are quite high versus comparable online brands.

Price Range: $1499-$3499

Final Score: 9.1 / 10

Get Yours Now

Read Full Review on Tempur-Pedic

#2 Restonic (Scott Living)Restonic makes multiple collections of mattresses that are found in both mattress stores and department stores across the country. Their Scott Living collection sold at Sears features innerspring and pocketed coil mattresses for a mid-grade price. Customers found them to be initially comfortable overall, but they are more expensive than top hybrid options found online, and there were a few reports of durability and firmness concerns.

The pros: A variety of innerspring mattress options by a reputable brand.

The cons: Expensive versus similar online brand products -- some durability complaints reported.

Price Range: $951-$5935

Final Score: 8.8 / 10

Read More Reviews About Restonic

#3 SimmonsSimmons makes a range of household name brands -- including their Beautyrest and Beautysleep product lines, both sold at Sears. Their Beautyrest mattresses have many different firmness options and also come in a variety of pricepoints. One of their most popular features is their pillow top, which gives the surface a cloud like feel on certain models. Overall, customers like their Simmons mattresses, but some had complaints about the durability.

The pros: Hybrid and innerspring mattresses with a variety of firmnesses and good initial comfort.

The cons: Some complaints of sagging and durability problems.

Price Range: $217-$13055

Final Score: 8.6 / 10

Online Only: Check Beautyrest Deals

Read More Reviews About Simmons

#4 Signature SleepSignature Sleep is on the higher end of the budget brand category. They sell a variety of memory foam and pocketed coil mattresses. With multiple firmness options and competitive pricing, they get good scores on initial comfort from customers. However, some had complaints about quick sagging problems so make sure to read the reviews.

The pros: More affordable mattress options with both memory foam and coil options.

The cons: Some customers had issues with durability and sagging.

Price Range: $97-$799

Final Score: 7.5 / 10

Read More Reviews About Signature Sleep

#5 Stearns & FosterStearns & Foster is a luxury mattress maker that has been around for decades. They have high thickness mattresses that feature luxury materials and traditional crafstmanship with modern advances. They get good feelings from customers for initial comfort, but there are some concerns about durability. Many customers report issues with sagging over a shorter than average timeframe.

The pros: Luxury mattresses with a variety of firmness options and high end materials.

The cons: Complaints about sagging over a shorter timeframe than average.

Price Range: $1151-$7219

Final Score: 7.3 / 10

Read More Reviews About Stearns & Foster

#6 SealySealy is well-known for its Posturepedic line that provides greater support where you need it most -- your lower back. They have multiple choices of firmness as well. The main negative is that some customers reported having problems with sagging over a short period.

The pros: Mattresses with multiple pricepoints that focus on better posture and back support.

The cons: Problems with sagging reported by some customers.

Price Range: $279-$6199

Final Score: 7.3 / 10

Read More Reviews About Sealy

#7 SertaSerta is another household name with their iComfort and iSeries brands. They have a wide array of price options for both low-budget and mid-grade shoppers. Also, they have both memory foam and innerspring choices. Most customers report feeling comfortable in their Serta mattresses at first, but there were problems with sagging reported by others.

The pros: Range of innerspring and memory foam mattresses at multiple pricepoints.

The cons: Problems with mattress longevity mentioned by some customers.

Price Range: $119-$4372

Final Score: 7.2 / 10
Read More Reviews About Serta

#8 Budget BrandsSears has budget brands available like Dorel and Wolf Corporation. These mattresses get mixed reviews from customers when it comes to comfort and others had problems with durability and sagging. If you are in the market for an affordable mattress, please take a look at our list of best mattresses for your money to get the best value.

The pros: Very affordable mattresses available in both innerspring and foam designs.

The cons: Reports of sagging and break down.

Price Range: $84-$664

Final Score: 6.9 / 10

Sears Mattress AlternativesSurprisingly, this has become one of the very best times to buy a new mattress. Over the last few years, there have been hundreds of new mattress brands that have come to market to compete for your business and this means:

Lower prices for better products if you know where to look.

Buying a mattress from an online brand direct is one of the best ways to get better quality materials and craftsmanship for less money. If you are willing to take a little extra time reading about which mattresses will fit your body and budget, it can save you $1000s of dollars and endless headaches.

If you are ready to learn more about why buying a mattress online direct from the brand is better than visiting a store in person, read our 2024 Mattress Buying Guide!

...or explore our reviews for the Top Rated Mattresses.