Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.
New Year's 2025 Updates: Beautyrest Silver is currently being sold at popular retailers like Costco, Walmart, and elsewhere. There are some reports of limited availability in certain models. Recent customers are mostly happy with mixed reviews about durability.
Beautyrest Silver is one of Beautyrest's most cost-effective mattress lines. Sold at Costco and another major discount retailers, Beautyrest Silver focuses on low cost mattresses without skimping on the mattress thickness. Overall, these mattresses are well regarded by customers, but there are some complaints about durability.
Overall Score: 8.2/10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.1/10
Price Value: 8/10
No Back Pain: 8.3/10
Price: $549-$1721
Trial Period: Depends on Retailer
See More ScoresThe Beautyrest Silver mattress line is one of Beautyrest's discount mattress offerings. With a focus on layers of foams above pocket coil support systems, they offer low costs for thick mattresses. While you may have to shop around for availability, there are multiple firmness options available, from plush to firm. However, when it comes to comfort, there are some mixed customer sentiment about these mattresses with some describing sagging and durability issues in some models.
Beautyrest Silver mattresses utilize mid-grade foams and pocket support systems. Due to the pricing model of these mattresses, with both brand and retailer marking up the mattresses, the value for the materials may be much lower than buying from an online brand that sells direct to customers.
Beautyrest Silver has multiple mattresses to choose from with some slight differences with their comfort layers so they can tailor to firmness specifications.
We'll go through the layers and call out potential differences:
Cover Layer: The cover layers are made with DualCool™ Plus that diffuses heat away from the body and wicks away moisture.
Top Comfort Layers: The first comfort layer depends somewhat on the model in terms of firmness. However, it features cooling foam and pressure relieving foam layers, sometimes with airy channels in the foam for better circulation. These layers do well with cooling and also are tailored to the firmness rating of the mattress selected.
Support Layers: The last layer is a pocketed coil support system with springs that adapt independently to the body's curves. This layer supplements the supportiveness of the layers above depending on the firmness selected.
Most customers find the Beautyrest Silver mattresses to be initially comfortable. One of the benefits of these mattresses is less partner disturbance, the firmness options, and also pressure relieving comfort layers. While most customers had good things to say at first, some mentioned firmness and durability concerns.
The Beautyrest Silver mattress line has a wide range of firmness options, which is ideal for those that are looking for something besides a standard medium-firm mattress. Those that are smaller and side sleepers may prefer a softer mattress, while those that are stomach sleepers or larger will desire a firmer mattress.
There were some mixed reviews about long term back pain relief with customers mentioning positive back pain relief less than average*.
Most sleepers will find these mattresses suitably cooling for them due to the top airy comfort layers and cooling cover. However, some in warmer environments may need something more specialized.
Those that are looking for a budget-friendly mattresses and need a wider range of firmness options can find something initially comfortable here. However, there are some doubts about the longevity from some reviewers.
We just received this week and it is perfect! I have to say it is hard to buy a mattress online but this was a great deal. We were looking for firm but nothing rock hard since I like to sleep on my side and I have hip issues but my husband loves to sleep on his back. So we compromised with this. We looked at Necturs and Tempurpetics types but they made me weary. Plus you have to have a certain bed frame (which we do not right now). We did not want a pillow top which did that before and that was mistake. Of course we were way overdo for a mattress but this was exactly what we were looking for. I am not sure it is real Plush..might be a little more in the middle. But everyone has different opinions. I went off the reviews and other research and it worked for me. A little soft but firmer. Setting delivery was a nightmare with XPO but hey, it was free. it got here in one piece.
We have had the mattress about one week and I have finally started to sleep through the night again! It is a little firmer than I thought it would be since we purchased the plush version, but still feels great. It is almost like you can feel the mattress contouring to your body. Also, I never feel the bed move when my partner turns.
Good support. Cool top.
No box spring and the mattress is so very thick, I need a boost to get into bed!
A great night sleep
Love it
Just what I wanted! Soft, cushy & well sewn!
I thought the top was going to be a bit more plush, however, the mattress is fantastic. Great buy.
This arrived on time and in good shape. It has good support but is plush enough to help eliminate my shoulder and hip pain. Our old mattress was over 10 years old, so this was an easy comparison.
So far so good. Only had it for a week but sleeping great and sleeping longer than usual. Previous mattress was waking me up early and often during the night.
I bought this King size mattress 2 weeks ago hoping it would be as good as the Queen size equivalent I already own. I am a side sleeper so as soon as I slept on it the first night, I knew something felt odd... my body was just uncomfortable. I soon realized that the mattress didn't need more time to adjust, it was simply dipping. I would expect King size mattresses to dip after a long time of wear but not on day 1! I asked my husband if his side was the same and sure enough, both sides did not have the support that I expected. Then I positioned my body in the center and realized that area was nicely supported. If this was done on purpose, this is one weird design. I am glad Costco has a good return policy because I would not find use for this mattress in my house.
Nice mattress but firmer than I thought it would be. I will be ordering a 2.5 inch foam gel top mattress topper to make it a little softer. I would prefer a firmer mattress to one too soft. It appears to be made very well.
Great product. Very comfortable bed for the in-laws bedroom
I have only had this PLUSH mattress for a couple of weeks but I already sleep better. This mattress is the only one that doesn’t seem too hard for me. The only thing I don’t care for is that it is higher than a standard mattress...I guess that if for the extra cushiness. Also, delivery was great!
comfy and not so heavy
I just received my new mattress and I am very very impressed!
Delivery was a week late, but wasn't a problem as this was a replacement mattress. Mattress is as expected.
Very comfortable mattress...exactly what we wanted. Shopped mattress store beforehand to compare and tryout. Our 900.00 mattress was comparable to a similar one priced at 3600.00 at the local mattress store. We are very satisfied
Very nice mattress
This mattress is so comfortable, firm and supportive. Great purchase.
Beautiful, sturdy, and a perfect fit!
This mattress is more "medium" than plush.
It’s more firm than you would expect a plush mattress to be. However it has been quite comfortable and we’re sleeping on it just fine. We both get shoulder pain if sleeping on the wrong mattress. I’m 5’3” and 110 lbs. husband is 5’7” and 160 lbs just for reference. We prefer to sleep on our sides.
Mattress was good. However they refused to take old mattress away which was reason I bought from Costco. The add clearly said old mattress would be removed.
Great mattress. It is not plush. I now sleep on my back. I hope it does not develop sags. I’m only 2 weeks into this mattress.
So comfy - awesome delivery service!
It’s hard as a rock. It hurt both of our backs
switched from a firm to a plush. and no more back ache
The mattress itself is fine, but without a set of springs, sits very low in most bed frames. That is a problem for the overall height of the bed (too low) and makes tucking in sheets and blankets more difficult.
Soft topper but it does have good support
Have only had it for two weeks. So far, it feels great.
It's nice, but not plush (imo). I would say more like comfort firm.
So far, after two restful nights, we can say we're happy with this mattress. As advertised, it is plush but with great support.
Ive tried four other mattresses (all much more expensive) and this is my favorite!!! love this mattress. I wanted a plush bed and it is definitely plush! So soft and cozy, yet supportive too. I’m so happy with this mattress.
This mattress doesn’t keep you as cool as I thought but it is quite comfortable. I would recommend.
If firmer mattresses have made you regret buying them and given you nothing but back pain and sleepless nights... and an expert like a chiropractor has recommended you find a more plush mattress... this is a great choice. Both my husband and I suffered from back pain and had trouble sleeping. My husband tends to be very warm and I am going through menopause... so we needed cooling down to be able to get some sleep. This mattress has made A-L-L the difference. I have always been a light sleeper and every little noise or movement would wake me. I now sleep during the whole night and don’t even feel my husband get up early in the mornings. I am so much more rested and refreshed in the mornings... I am a morning person again!
Firm but comfortable mattress. We couldn't be happier with our choice.
It’s quite comfy. It’s a pretty tall mattress. I wish I had gone 12 instead of 14 inches.
After years of sleeping uncomfortably on a mattress that was too firm it was a welcomed relief to find a mattress that was not to soft or too firm to sleep on. Very pleased that I found a mattress with the desired comfort level that I was searching for.
It’s Comfortable for the first couple nights then it Sinks to the middle, I don’t know think you can retune this items.
This is a very firm mattress
I was hopeful about this mattress. It wasn't to be - from the first night it was uncomfortable and I started having terrible aches and pains. It is not very soft - there is a soft layer on top, but underneath that it is hard. Even my husband said that it is a firm mattress. It started having an indentation after a few days - we are not large people. I am 5'2" 135, My husband is 5'10, 150. I returned it an purchased a mattress elsewhere. I love Costco and their return policy, but it seems that they do not sell high-quality, well made mattresses that are truly soft.
This was the feel we were looking for. At first we purchased a Firm mattress, but felt like we were sleeping on a board. Yes, we gave it a 4 week trial. Now we exchanged it for this Plush mattress and have been very satisfied. The was the supported, yet soft feel we were looking for.
Very supportive. The 'new' order of modern mattress. good balance of price/value.
Bed is very comfortable, not sure what the cooling part is because I don't notice that but it is a nice mattress and I'm happy with it.
Very comfortable. I ordered plush it is very plush. Does not smell. Edges have good support. A little bit warm but it's not bad. I would recommend this.
There was nothing plush about this bed
Mattress says plush its more like medium to firm. It also took costco 5 weeks to get it to me
This mattress is not plush. It is very firm. It appears to be well made.
Purchased the queen size mattress. It wasn’t as ‘Plush’ as I expected, i.e. a bit firmer, but surprisingly comfortable. Just bought another one.
Very comfortable and came earlier than expected.
Comfortable mattress.
This is a very comfortable matress, but it is warm. It would be nice if it had the cooling gel.
We purchased from Costco and returned after one night sleep. The bed looks great and I’m sure comfortable for some, but this mattress is not plush, it is pretty firm. Returned and purchased a medium firm with plush pillow top mattress. Huge difference.
It’s definitely one of the most back supporting mattress we’ve ever owned. It’s feels more like a medium soft with plenty of back support. It did take three weeks to get, thanks to COVID 19.
We bought this bed for my brother who is disabled he is in the bed about 1/2 of the day. He said his body feels better and that he sleeps so much better. It defiantly is getting 5 stars from our family
It is extremely firm, not at all plush! Unfortunately we had to returned it.
I have slept on three beds for the past eight years and all of them hurt my back. I finally decided that I had had it and got on costco.com and found this Beautyrest mattress. I was nervous to order it online without having had an opportunity to lie on it, but I'm so happy that I just went for it. For the first time I don't wake up with back pain and I am even able to lie on my back without pain if I want to. Before I could only tolerate side sleeping. I sink in to it, yet it offers support. This mattress is your favorite comfy couch in bed form.
Comfortable and works well for me
Great value. Comfortable mattress with a nice pillow top. Perfect compromise between firm and soft. You will not sink in to this mattress but soft enough for a good night sleep.
I tried the Stern & Foster Kirkland mattress but found it too quilted making it feel lumpy. This mattress feels good to me.
Great product
All is well and enjoying the Beautyrest Silver 14.5".
The pillow top is just plush enough to hug my body and the springs are firm enough to feel like I am being supported, it is kind of the perfect in between. As a bonus the dual cool definitely works as this thing actually breathes, and I don't sweat nearly as much with this as I did with my old mattress.
So far it is just fine. Was hoping for a bit more softness but have been sleeping comfortably.
I earlier reviewed this item negatively due to factors related to delivery issues related to the Coronavirus. We have now slept on this mattress nightly for almost three months and absolutely love it. It comfortably supports my husband’s bad back with its firm foundation yet the plush upper top gives an inviting comfort that invites sleep. We have spent much more on previous mattresses yet none has given the same level of satisfaction than this.
I feel badly returning this mattress during COVID. I have tried and tried to adjust to it. I spend a great deal of time in bed because of a dumb chronic illness and it just doesn't work for us. We both always roll to the middle. And he snores.
For us the mattress was just not the right fit. We were sleeping on an older Tempur-pedic and when we put the new Beautyrest on the box springs it was too hard. We took it off the box springs and it still was a bit too stiff for us. It is a move bed just not what we were looking for.
The mattress is just awesome and I love it
My pregnant wife and I selected this mattress, on sale, off costco.com due to its affordability, name brand, and features of inner spring coils and foam layers. The right side of the mattress slept quite firm, like a new mattress would be expected to sleep. The left side was oddly unsupportive, completely different from the right side. When sleeping on the left side, you sank into the cushion layers down to the coils, but the coils were still extremely firm. Very very uncomfortable to say the least. Overall, this was more of a firm mattress rather than a Plush mattress.
Comfortable and cooling
Excellent sleeping experience.
Very comfortable, good middle between soft and firm.
This product was exactly as I had expected ...
Incredibly comfy mattress
Our old plush mattress was lumpy and uneven, so we were looking for something with a little less give. The description says medium mattress. It is firm. Very firm. We had hoped to get rid of our foam topper, but after 2 nights, we added it back on. Other than the extra height, it seems to be comfortable with the topper. If you want plush, this is not the mattress you want.
Outside of it being a one sided mattress it’s a very good mattress.
I Love My New Mattress!! To Me, I’m sleeping on a cloud! Thank you!
This mattress is great! It’s very comfortable, and I would definitely recommend it.
This mattress is wonderful. I took a chance on this and it payed off. I would buy it again!
This mattress is well made but it was too firm for me. If you are a back sleeper it is more comfortable but for me being a side sleeper it wasn't.
Bought this mattress in 2020 right after pandemic. Probably stayed in it more than usual but it was the worst mattress. Started to sink in spots and springs started to poke. My husband and I are at slim build so this shouldn't be any issue but just not durable at all. Dont buy if you have back, neck or hip pain. Maybe for a slim teenager or something.
*All metrics regarding customer sentiment are based on aggregated public review content, including reviews that have been submitted to this site and elsewhere that have been evaluated by our data science team. While we strive to provide useful metrics for the benefit of shoppers, we cannot certify their accuracy at any given time due to potentially incomplete and inaccurate data sources.
Furniture shopping is an oftentimes tedious and mundane task. This site's sole purpose is to help you make the decision faster and with more peace of mind. We sincerely hope that whatever your interaction with this site, that it is helpful and timely for you, and that the product information here guides you to the best outcome for your daily life. May all benefit! The reviews here are aggregated from other sources across the Internet and although we have tried only to find trustworthy reviews, the content and scores here may be subject to manipulation by agents acting on behalf of manufacturers and marketers. Like all things you read on the Internet, understand there is no better judge than yourself. When it comes to your own comfort, your own body is the only North Star. Where Slumber Search discusses medical ailments, we strive to ensure the information on this site is accurate, current and useful, however, we do not warrant the accuracy or completeness of any information related to medicine. We are not doctors -- if you have a medical condition, please consult your doctor.
The makers of Slumber Search also make affiliate commissions from some of these manufacturers to keep the site running. There is NO additional price markup for using this site or on links from this site and any commissions made by Slumber Search come out of the brand's profit margin. See how it all works here.
SLUMBER SEARCH
