Amerisleep vs. Puffy
Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.
Amerisleep
Amerisleep offers a line of high-end memory foam and hybrid mattresses that offer the benefits of plant-based materials. Each mattress has a blend of bio-foams for comfort layers that are more eco-friendly than the traditional synthetic-based memory foam material. Amerisleep offers 5 different mattress firmness options in all-foam options, 3 popular firmness varieties in a pocketed coil hybrid build, and a natural latex hybrid. Customers like their offerings and have good things to say about the quality versus better known name-brands.
Puffy
Puffy is an online mattress brand that makes four mattresses: The Puffy Cloud Mattress, The Puffy Lux Mattress, The Puffy Royal Mattress, and The Puffy Monarch Mattress. Each of these offer a highly rated, pressure-relieving feel that is making a splash in the mattress in a box industry. Folks find Puffy's mattresses more plush than many other options, which is great for those with a lighter body type. With a goal of providing a balanced, fluffy feel for less than in-store and a lineup that includes both all-foam and hybrid designs, Puffy is worth a second look!
Based on our aggregated reviews and our scoring method, we recommend Puffy in this match up!
Mattress Score
Overall Score:
Amerisleep: 9.2/10
Puffy: 9.4/10
Customer Satisfaction:
Amerisleep: 9.1/10
Puffy: 9.4/10
Price Value:
Amerisleep: 9.1/10
Puffy: 9.4/10
No Back Pain:
Amerisleep: 9/10
Puffy: 9.4/10
Price:
Amerisleep: $1049-$3898
Puffy: $1949-$6698
Amerisleep:
Get $500 Off Mattresses
Puffy:
Get $1350 In Savings
Amerisleep's Owner Satisfaction
Reading online reviews is a wonderful way to find out if a specific product will work for you. Customers rate these mattresses highly for comfort, but there are some that didn't feel as good with the mattresses. Look at the details below to see if one of these will work for you.
Amerisleep's Supportiveness
These mattresses aren't ideal for everyone in terms of their support. Though there are some who like the response of these mattresses, some have found these mattresses to be disagreeable with their body. If you are thinking about this mattress, make sure that it works for your body before buying.
Edge Support
Edge support is always important to those who like sitting on the side of the bed. Some folks, however, don't report it being as large of an issue for them. Overall these mattresses aren't as supportive over the long term so if edge support is important, make sure to do extra research.
Amerisleep's Durability
Good craftsmanship, materials, and quality control will more than likely lead to good durability. Reviewers may have issues if brands forget some of these attributes. Unfortunately, these mattresses get mixed reviews from customers on durability. There are some customers that have complaints about comfort over the short term, while others report a happy night's sleep. Do a final rundown of the reviews before you purchase.
Puffy's Owner Satisfaction
Customer satisfaction is a good foundation to looking more into a mattress. Based on online customer sentiment and review data, these mattresses are highly regarded by customers. Overall, customers are comfortable with these mattresses and report having good experiences with the brand itself. Take a look below to learn if this mattress will work for you!
Puffy's Supportiveness
These mattresses are above average when it comes to support. Though some reviewers don't agree 100% with the firmness specs of these mattresses, the majority of reviewers describe them as having the right amount of support for deep sleep.
Edge Support
Edge support is really important for those that struggle with mobility or like to put weight on the side of the mattress. These mattresses are well rated by most on edge support and they should be able to support most customers.
Bowling Ball & Density Tests
Many mattress reviewers and bloggers use bowling balls to measure firmness and support. These mattresses are generally well received at providing even support, which means they should do well comfortably responding to your body.
Puffy's Durability
Customers are always on the lookout for highly durable mattresses. But with companies focusing less on building quality products and more on shipping product, it can be a hard thing to find a mattress that will last. That said, these mattresses are rated highly for durability. They will last between 7 - 12 years for the average sleeper. If you are heavier or use your mattress more than nightly, then you may expect a little less durability.
Browse Amerisleep Customer Reviews
Amazing
This is hands down the best bed I've ever owned. I'm a side sleeper and would constantly wake up with my arm asleep or back pain or hip pain. I've had this bed for 3 months and that has not happened once! I look forward to going to bed every day now and sleep all the way through the night.
Show More Reviews Show Less Reviews
Great Customer Service
I originally ordered the AS3 but it was too firm so we returned it and later ordered the AS5. The AS5 is perfect. Customer support was excellent. We had a very positive experience with both purchases and the return of the AS3.
Second Purchase
We purchased a full size mattress for our guest bedroom. This is the second Amerisleep mattress we have. We have a queen mattress in our master suite. The beds are very comfortable and a firm without being too firm.
Look no further for a great mattress
While visiting Seattle we had the chance to sleep on the AS5 mattress. Both my wife and myself commented on the good night's sleep we had. On the 2nd night I woke up with no stiffness in my lower back. After sleeping on this mattress for 10 nights we decided to order it to be delivered to our Ocala FL home. This mattress replaced our Temper pedic pillow top mattress that we paid $4,200 12 years ago. The mattress arrived a few days after we returned home. It was s sizable box but I was able to drag it the master bedroom. Now I had a problem as I still had the Temper Pedic to get rid of. The TP was too heavy, too big and too clumsy for 2 - 3 people to handle, so I got a serrated blade knife and cut it into manageable pieces to trash. I then proceeded to unbox the AS5 and got it onto the platform boxes. The AS5 took a few hours to expand and was ready for us when it was time to go to bed. There were no odors or gassing of the AS5 and it was just as comfortable as the one we slept on in Seattle. WHAT A GOOD PURCHASE
I tried AS3 first but then got the AS5. Could not be happier
I like a soft mattress but not so I feel like I sink in at the hips. I also want to lay on my side and not feel the pressure on my rib cage. I don't know how they do it but this AS5 mattress is simply a miracle. I would rate it as the best surface for sleeping since I had a perfectly filled water bed. Those of you who liked water beds will understand what I am saying. This bed cradles you and supports. I love the way it feels when I am on my side or my back. Sometimes I sleep on my stomach but that is rare and I will say, I feel the extra extension in my back. If you do lots of stomach sleeping, this bed is not for you. Amerisleep was very patient with me as I explored three different mattresses. AS3 is a very fine mattress but just a little too firm. AS4 had that "stuck" feeling and really did not relieve pressure points with me. I was worried that the AS5 would be too soft but the bounce of the Active Flex layer is amazing. You will pay much more for this mattress but it is worth it. I hope this continues to be a mattress available from Amerisleep. I have had this mattress for the last 5 months. I have had the best night's sleep of my life, since getting this mattress. I do not like to leave home because I will be away from this bed. I am a 60 year old man who is in relatively good shape, 5' 7", 166 pounds.
Best mattress ever!
We've had this mattress for a year or so now. Love it!
good.
happy with the mattress. works very well with the adjustable mattress frame I got. the A5 is the "softest" and im very content with it. Recommend going into the store and trying them all out to find your best fit.
A soft alternative to a Stearns pillow top. Well made.
The bed is a huge upgrade over a 2 year old soft pillow top Stearns and Foster. We chose the softest one in the Amerisleep line worried that it would be too soft but actually it's not even as soft as we hoped it would be but still better than what we had, kind of wish there was an A6. We're not big people so maybe that has something to do with it. I'm almost six feet a hundred seventy pounds and I don't sink into the mattress nearly as much as I thought I would. Have some pressure points on my hips and at times it's still a little bit sore to sleep on one side but that might have more to do with my age than the mattress itself.
Best matress ever
Mattress is as expected. Takes awhile to soften up and conform to your body but once it's there. There is no bed that can beat it
Good memory foam
Bed is soft. I personally didn't take to the memory foam and will go back to a innerspring.
Amazing
This is hands down the best bed I've ever owned. I'm a side sleeper and would constantly wake up with my arm asleep or back pain or hip pain. I've had this bed for 3 months and that has not happened once! I look forward to going to bed every day now and sleep all the way through the night.
Great Customer Service
I originally ordered the AS3 but it was too firm so we returned it and later ordered the AS5. The AS5 is perfect. Customer support was excellent. We had a very positive experience with both purchases and the return of the AS3.
Second Purchase
We purchased a full size mattress for our guest bedroom. This is the second Amerisleep mattress we have. We have a queen mattress in our master suite. The beds are very comfortable and a firm without being too firm.
Look no further for a great mattress
While visiting Seattle we had the chance to sleep on the AS5 mattress. Both my wife and myself commented on the good night's sleep we had. On the 2nd night I woke up with no stiffness in my lower back. After sleeping on this mattress for 10 nights we decided to order it to be delivered to our Ocala FL home. This mattress replaced our Temper pedic pillow top mattress that we paid $4,200 12 years ago. The mattress arrived a few days after we returned home. It was s sizable box but I was able to drag it the master bedroom. Now I had a problem as I still had the Temper Pedic to get rid of. The TP was too heavy, too big and too clumsy for 2 - 3 people to handle, so I got a serrated blade knife and cut it into manageable pieces to trash. I then proceeded to unbox the AS5 and got it onto the platform boxes. The AS5 took a few hours to expand and was ready for us when it was time to go to bed. There were no odors or gassing of the AS5 and it was just as comfortable as the one we slept on in Seattle. WHAT A GOOD PURCHASE
I tried AS3 first but then got the AS5. Could not be happier
I like a soft mattress but not so I feel like I sink in at the hips. I also want to lay on my side and not feel the pressure on my rib cage. I don't know how they do it but this AS5 mattress is simply a miracle. I would rate it as the best surface for sleeping since I had a perfectly filled water bed. Those of you who liked water beds will understand what I am saying. This bed cradles you and supports. I love the way it feels when I am on my side or my back. Sometimes I sleep on my stomach but that is rare and I will say, I feel the extra extension in my back. If you do lots of stomach sleeping, this bed is not for you. Amerisleep was very patient with me as I explored three different mattresses. AS3 is a very fine mattress but just a little too firm. AS4 had that "stuck" feeling and really did not relieve pressure points with me. I was worried that the AS5 would be too soft but the bounce of the Active Flex layer is amazing. You will pay much more for this mattress but it is worth it. I hope this continues to be a mattress available from Amerisleep. I have had this mattress for the last 5 months. I have had the best night's sleep of my life, since getting this mattress. I do not like to leave home because I will be away from this bed. I am a 60 year old man who is in relatively good shape, 5' 7", 166 pounds.
Best mattress ever!
We've had this mattress for a year or so now. Love it!
good.
happy with the mattress. works very well with the adjustable mattress frame I got. the A5 is the "softest" and im very content with it. Recommend going into the store and trying them all out to find your best fit.
A soft alternative to a Stearns pillow top. Well made.
The bed is a huge upgrade over a 2 year old soft pillow top Stearns and Foster. We chose the softest one in the Amerisleep line worried that it would be too soft but actually it's not even as soft as we hoped it would be but still better than what we had, kind of wish there was an A6. We're not big people so maybe that has something to do with it. I'm almost six feet a hundred seventy pounds and I don't sink into the mattress nearly as much as I thought I would. Have some pressure points on my hips and at times it's still a little bit sore to sleep on one side but that might have more to do with my age than the mattress itself.
Best matress ever
Mattress is as expected. Takes awhile to soften up and conform to your body but once it's there. There is no bed that can beat it
Good memory foam
Bed is soft. I personally didn't take to the memory foam and will go back to a innerspring.
Very happy
Very happy with this bed, would buy it again
Excellent nights's sleep
We have been sleeping on a queen bed. When we decided to upsize to a king bed we bought a Casper... the softest one they had. I never was able to get comfortable on it. We returned it after about 30 days and bought the amerisleep. I have slept very well since. It is very soft, yet supports my body well. I am very happy with it.
A great mattress for bony side-sleepers!
Because of our narrow staircase to a converted loft, we had to choose a mattress in a box or we could not do a king-sized mattress. While heavy, the Amerisleep mattress was manageable up the stairs and very easy to open. I love that it did not off-gas at all. Zero. We've slept on it for more than a month now and it's starting to soften considerably. Perfect for both of us as we are side sleepers who need a softer mattress for our pressure points. I don't wake up sore anymore.
Best is yet to come
We tried several other brands with no luck or inaccurate descriptions and non could compare to the legacy of Amerisleep.
I love my mattress
Love how it feels. Love how it cradles my body.
Great mattress, just a little too firm for us
This mattress was heat reducing, did not hold you in place, and did not hold its indentations long at all. It was a little too firm for our tastes, but otherwise we would have been more than happy to keep it.
Good mattress
My husband and I bought a high end mattress a few years ago and within 6 months it had valleys where we normally sleep. In the middle was a mountain. It became uncomfortable quickly. I searched for a new mattress for several years. The return policy on this mattress was the big seller for me. It has maintained its comfort since day 1.
I would definitely buy this product again.
We are both back and side sleepers and the mattress works great for us. This mattress made sleeping with a bad hip before and after hip replacement surgery possible. Our old mattress made sleeping especially on the side intolerable.
Best Sleep Ever!
Me and my better half haven't had a better sleep in years; we are very happy with Amerisleep!
Great bed! Tried MANY others. This is the one.
I tried 5 other beds (including Purple2) and sent them all back. I am a side sleeper and have point-pain in hips and shoulders. 95+% of the time I wake up free of pain. Other beds advertised comfort but this bed IS comfortable. Only minor downside was an extended period of off-gassing. This disappeared in less than a week but was noticeable. Overall, very happy with this bed!
Very excellent product
I have slept on a Tempurpedic mattress for the past 15 years, one for 10 years and the other for 5 years. I had problems with shoulder pressure point pain for several years and then hip pressure point pain with the Tempurpedic. Much better with Amerisleep.
No regrets. Best mattress I've ever slept on!
I Bought the AS5 as my primary bed. Was s little afraid of it sleeping hot, but that's not the case at all. In fact I sleep cooler than my old pillow top Serta traditional mattress. Im a side sleeper so I went with the softest option Amerisleep had to offer. I love my bed and literally look forward to crawling into it every night.
New to Memory Foam
I bought this to replace my old mattress which was terribly uncomfortable. I did loads of research because my current mattress was putting a lot of pressure on my hips and causing me to wake up in the middle of the night in pain. I finally decided to go with the AS5 because I wanted a soft mattress with support because I am a side sleeper. This was my first memory foam mattress and I had read mixed reviews so I was nervous about having an adjustment period and not being able to rest during that time. For me there was no adjustment with this mattress I slept great the first night and every night since then. I no longer wake up with pain in my hips and legs and it's amazing. I have had this mattress for 6 months and haven't noticed any sunken areas or any change in the mattress, it is holding up really well. It is a nice soft mattress but it's not really the sink 2 inches in kind of soft I was expecting. Initially I was concerned because I really wanted that super soft feeling but I think now I prefer the way it is because it's easier to get out of and turn over in and I don't get too hot while I'm sleeping. I would advise investing in a good mattress cover and an adjustable base if you can. I hope this helps someone with their decision :)
We finally found a keeper!!!
After trying 3 other beds since Nov 2017, we tried the Amerisleep and finally found our bed. Yes we tried 3 others and returned all 3 before there 100 day guarantees. This bed is as comfortable as the $4,000 competitor and has provided us the very needed good night sleep we didn't have for years on our old traditional mattress or the other 3 we tried. It was a very frustrating year buying beds and finding them not to be what they advertised, but this bed actually is what it has advertised.
I would recommend this mattress again. It is very comfortabl
Great night sleep.
Great for a side sleeper
I have been searching for a bed that will be comfortable for a side sleeper--which is how I primarily sleep. I have been suffereing from hip, shoulder and back pains for several years because of mattresses that are too firm. This mattress allows me to sleep on my side comfortably. Sometimes, my back gets a bit stiff or achey when I lay on my back, but since I don't typically sleep that way, it's ok.
Great customer service
Great customer service. Soft supporrive mattress.
We love our new Amerisleep mattress!!
My husband and I purchased this as a new bed for ourselves. We both suffer from back problems and I found myself waking up many mornings to aches and pains in my hips and shoulders. I researched mattresses extensively - Amerisleep just stood out! I like that Amerisleep looks at how people sleep and makes their mattresses accordingly. Mattresses are not an easy purchase, especially with so many options out there, but Amerisleep made this process a breeze! We purchased the AS5 and we love it! It is soft and comfy, yet supportive. We are sleeping so much better and I'm not waking up with hip and shoulder pain! We've even noticed a decrease in snoring. :) Also, temperature control seems to be a concern with memory foam mattresses but we've had not issues with getting too warm. I highly recommend Amerisleep and wish we would've purchased this bed a long time ago!!
I love this mattress!!!
I love this mattress , I always fall asleep so fast. I have a queen and king size mattress from amerisleep and love them both. The mattress itself is so comfortable that I never want to leave my bed.
Good purchase
I was originally opposed to spending 2000$ on a king size luxury mattress. But every time I climb into bed it feels so soft. And if you think about it you spend a third of your life in bed. Best splurge ever. Highly recommend the AS5. I'm not sure about their other models, but the AS5 KING size is better than any hotel mattress we have used in the past.
Browse Puffy Customer Reviews
No more back pain
No bounce. Very comfortable. Had some minor back pain with the old mattress and now it's gone!
Show More Reviews Show Less Reviews
Soft & Firm
This Puffy is just the perfect amount of soft & firm and we can't stop loving it.
Great price, great support
After 2 weeks of having the Puffy mattress, I can say that is has been nothing but pure pleasure sleeping on it at nights. It took us couple nights to adjust from a spring type to a memory type but now there is no way I will ever sleep on a spring one again. I feel it slightly adjusting to my body and protecting my pressure points. In my opinion is on the firmer side and that's why I like it so much. My last mattress was on the softer side and after 6 months it started to get deformed. We have been very happy with our mattress so far.
I sleep much better because of this mattress.
Wonderful quality mattress! Never expected it to be this nice right out of the box.
5 stars
Arrived at our door quickly. No strong odor out of the box and it expanded within minutes so we even slept on it that very same night even though they say it fully expands in 24-48 hours.
Delivery was on time
Recommend it! I have to give it up to Puffy for having not only a perfect mattress for my wife and kids, but also having a customer service team that will go out of their way to help us out. For some reason FedEx was not updating the tracking information for 2 days, so I called in and the service team member helped us track it down a assured us that we will be getting the mattress.
Way better than my $4k mattress
WOW Great Price. Very nice cover and overall cloud design. We literally saved a few thousand dollars on this mattress, we made the purchase for the King 2 months ago so I had time to check it out before writing something on here. My wife and I both agree that Puffy has very good body support that does allow and sagging into the bed. I used to move around a lot at nights causing my wife to wake up so that problem is solved. I move around a lot less now and when I do she says she doesn't feel anything and sleeps through he night.
Mary
So far so good with our Puffy Mattress
Cooler nights
My old mattress was a heat magnet. My fav thing about this new mattress is that it does not trap heat like my old Temper Pedic did. I would definitely recommend this mattress especially for the price, it is a great one.
Buy One. NOW.
This mattress is the bomb. It's literally the best ever. Highly recommend it to any and everyone. I like soft mattresses and my wife likes firm ones and we're both ecstatic about it. She's also 36+ weeks pregnant and sleeps like a newborn on it. Plus, it was cheaper than our last brand new mattress from Mattress Firm. Go get one!
Wonderful
We were sceptical to purchase a mattress that we had not only never heard of but also never tried out, but this proved to be a great risk to take. The mattress is as described, very supportive without feeling like a very firm mattress. We had been sleeping on a Sleep Number bed for 15+ years so needed to renew the bed. We had only considered another Sleep Number bed (because we had heard that it was the best out there)until my husband did some reseach into what had been voted as the most comfortable bed by consumers and thats when he found out about the Puffy. Now we have changed our opinion and will definitly by the Puffy mattress for the other beds in the house as they need changing. We would highly recommend this mattress.
Like the feel
like the feel of the mattress however, i'm not quite convinced. I am having back issues, not sure if they are due to having a foam mattress, new mattress or just not a right fit for me.
Puffy is awesome
Love it very comfortable easy to put together!!
Good mattress. Pleased so far
Good mattress. Pleased so far
wonderful!!!!!!
wonderful!!!!!!
Haven’t slept this good in
Haven’t slept this good in a long time. Makes it hard to get up for work in the morning.
My wife and I love
My wife and I love it.
Great top quality mattress
My daughter says the best sleep she has ever had.
Sleeping through the night
I had called myself a light sleeper pre-Puffy. I am now sleeping through the night and feeling great’
Puffy purchase
WOW! We Love our new puffy mattress
Love it
It’s soft but holds you firmly. I love it. It helps my back and hip pain.
Great Purchase
I wanted to wait a couple of weeks before I sent my review. The purchase and shipping were great, arrived in 4 days to my front door:) my lowered back feels better that it has in years. I sleep soundly through most of the night and I like that I don't disturb anyone when I roll around etc!
And then I wake up
I've had my Puffy Mattress for about 1 week. I'm still getting used to it. All I can say is I go to bed about 11ish then my alarm sounds at 6 am. By day 3, I did not wake up exhausted and stiff. I'm sleeping through the night. I love it.
The cloud is King
I just recently moved and took a chance on purchasing 2 queen size Puffy mattresses based on reviews. I am so happy I did for as the name implies, its like sleeping on a cloud. Very very comfortable and no more back pain. Thank you Puffy. Ron Ret USN Submarines
Like sleeping on a cloud
I’m in love with this mattress - it’s like sleeping on a cloud. It’s not too firm or too soft, it’s just right and makes you feel very light.
Puffy is Perfect!
My husband and I both love the new Puffy mattress we ordered. No complaints from either of us. I am sleeping so much better!
Love this mattress, so far, so good
We've had our bed for less then a month and so far it has been a great mattress. I've been sleeping very solid, not waking up in the middle of the night. The whole experience has been great. Thank you!
Love Love Love it! Super
Love Love Love it! Super comfortable on my hips. Stays cool to sleep. Finally sleeping thru the night again. Highly recommend giving this mattress a try.
Puffy Save
This mattress saved my back. The pain I woke up with every morning was gone after the first night of sleep on this mattress. Now I’m waking up earlier feeling more rested.
Awesome!
Very comfortable. We love it!
Larry
This mattress is a great one we really like it!
Puff Full Size memory form
Went from 5 hours a night to easily 8 hours of good sleep within 3 days after I got it.
Recently Purchased Puffy Mattress
Two words: LIFE CHANGING!
Finally
My 3rd mattress. No need to break it in. Which some mattress company's say you need to do. Comfy from the start. I started to wonder If I would ever find a mattress that would help my aches and pains. It's all good. We're happy
Very good quality
We’ve only had our Puffy mattress for about a week, but so far so good!! It is quite firm but very supportive. We like a little softness on the top of our mattress and since you don’t get that with any memory foam mattress, we added a fiberbed mattress pad on top. The mattress is very good quality.
Great mattress
Best night sleep in years. Quick and easy ordering and FAST shipping. Highly recommend
extremely comfortable.
great for my shoulders and hip pains. would highly recommend.
Mattress is comfortable
I think the mattress is very comfortable, my neck pain has completely disappeared. However I am a back sleeper and I can't sleep very well due to getting extremely hot and sweaty. Hopefully this will get better cause it's very difficult to get any sleep when you feel so hot/cold. I also Love that we can get in and out of bed without disturbing each other. Its amazing. Our old bed squeeked and bounced when one of us even moved or adjusted.
So far so good it
So far so good it has only been 1 week
Fantastic don’t hesitate
Wow you can rest assured this is a quality investment you will be telling your friends and family about